Google+
Language
Search

Prop65News

Covering Proposition 65 News and Events Since 1987




Governor Brown Signs Proposition 65 Reform Bill

Governor Brown Signs Proposition 65 Reform Bill

Amendments Take Effect on Jan. 1, 2018

Author: Jack Schatz/Friday, October 06, 2017/Categories: California Legislation, Prop65, Litigation, Attorney General

Rate this article:
No rating

 

California Governor Jerry Brown has signed a Proposition 65 reform bill that amends the statute to make the contents of a private plaintiff’s basis for its Certificate of Merit discoverable to the extent that the information is relevant to the subject matter of the action and not subject to the attorney-client privilege, the attorney work product privilege, or any other legal privilege.

The amendment also requires the Attorney General to send a letter to the private enforcer and the recipients of the 60-day notice when the Attorney General has reviewed the certificate of merit and determined that there is no merit to an action.

The amendment to the statute under AB 1583 will take effect on January 1, 2018.

The amendment address ambiguity in the current statute, which provides that the factual basis of a certificate of merit is not discoverable unless it is relevant to the subject matter and otherwise discoverable. 

 

This language has resulted in most private plaintiffs taking the position that the basis for the certificate is never discoverable. The amendment brings clarity to language that was murky at best.  Going forward defendants will have a prima facie right to seek discovery of the factual basis of the certificate.  The citizen enforcer would carry the burden of justifying any privilege or attorney work product objections, as is the case when privilege is asserted in other situations.

 

While the Attorney General has seldom published opinions on the question of whether a Certificate of merit, is not meritorious, and the criteria used by the Office of the Attorney General is unclear, it remains to be seen what impact this provision may have.

Assemblyman Chau’s bill was widely accepted by the regulated community and faced no organized opposition.


 

 

California Governor Jerry Brown has signed a Proposition 65 reform bill that amends the statute to make the contents of a private plaintiff’s basis for its Certificate of Merit discoverable to the extent that the information is relevant to the subject matter of the action and not subject to the attorney-client privilege, the attorney work product privilege, or any other legal privilege.

The amendment also requires the Attorney General to send a letter to the private enforcer and the recipients of the 60-day notice when the Attorney General has reviewed the certificate of merit and determined that there is no merit to an action.

The amendment to the statute under AB 1583 will take effect on January 1, 2018.

The amendment address ambiguity in the current statute, which provides that the factual basis of a certificate of merit is not discoverable, unless it is relevant to the subject matter and otherwise discoverable. 

This language has resulted in most private plaintiffs taking the position that the basis for the certificate is never discoverable. The amendment brings clarity to language that was murky at best.  Going forward defendants will have a prima facie right to seek discovery of the factual basis of the certificate.  The citizen enforcer would carry the burden of justifying any privilege or attorney work product objections, as is the case when privilege is asserted in other situations.

While the Attorney General has seldom published opinions on the question of whether a Certificate of merit, is not meritorious, and the criteria used by the Office of the Attorney General is unclear, it remains to be seen what impact this provision may have.

Assemblyman Chau’s bill was widely accepted by the regulated community and faced no organized opposition.

Print

Number of views (138)/Comments (0)

Jack Schatz

Jack Schatz

Other posts by Jack Schatz
Contact author

Please login or register to post comments.

Name:
Email:
Subject:
Message:
x

Filter:

Sort by:

Filter by Authors

Proposition 65 Regulations

Implementing Regulations
Prop 65 Made Simple

FAQs

Prop 65 Appellate Opinions
Statute

Proposition 65 Law Firms and Experts


            List Your Company Now!

MoFo-Logo636136432680764777


Prop 65 Chemicals
Proposition 65 Chemical List 
Safe Harbor Levels
Chemicals Under Consideration

 

Proposition 65 Handbook 2013 Edition
The Proposition 65 Handbook - 2017 Edition is available for immediate shipment.
To learn more about the latest edition of this indispensable desk reference    
click here.



Terms Of UsePrivacy StatementCopyright 1987 - 2017 Cornerstone Publishing, LLC